Welcome to the Planet London Reviews page. You are welcome to comment on these reviews.

Sunday, 24 April 2011

The Madness of Sister George (film)

“Impossible to use one word to describe it”

A quote from Beryl Reid herself when trying to sum up ‘The Killing of Sister George’.  I couldn’t agree more.  It is often described as a comedy and yet I find the film both harrowing and sad.  There are lines to make you laugh - Beryl Reid is given the best ones and plays them perfectly -   but a comfortable watch this is not as we take a journey with these characters through power, loss, change and desire.  

Writing about this film will involve some spoilers so if you have yet to see it be aware.  The film was originally a play in 1964 and also starred Beryl Reid.  In 1968 director Robert Aldrich (also known for directing ‘Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?’) brought it to screen and it became the first explicit representation of lesbianism in a Hollywood film. At the time both the UK and US press claimed it was a shocking revelation into a hidden world

The film centres around June Buckridge (Beryl Reid) who is an actress in ‘Applehurst’ – a BBC televison series. She plays a character called ‘Sister George’, much loved, kind to those around her.  In real life she is the opposite, a drunken foul mouthed, sadistic rather butch lesbian.  She is known as ‘George’ to everyone and rarely hides her true character– even living openly with another woman, Alice ‘Childe’ McNaught (Susannah York), a younger woman with a collection of Victorian dolls, who bears the brunt of George’s verbal and psychological assaults.  

The volatile nature of their relationship is a complex one – swinging from serious to comic – and if at first we wonder why the two are together, the numerous insights into the differences and tensions between the characters show us it is perhaps these differences that bring them together and the relationship seems to suit them both.  

For Childe it is a need to have a roof over her head and a ‘mother’ figure and for George a need for love and affection.  George perhaps also likes to believe Childe needs her, “you couldn’t cross a road by yourself”, she says at one point to Childe. As the film progresses we see Childe growing stronger and more rebellious and it’s only when she admits “we have been together a long time, besides I don’t really have anywhere else to go” that we can draw our own conclusions.

George’s comment, “remember who pays the rent” perhaps makes us realise how insecure both of these characters are.
The fact that George may be on the brink of losing her job threatens her ‘role’ as provider and more importantly the relationship with Alice.  If she can’t provide security for her and Alice then where does that leave them?  


The numerous arguments make for difficult watching.  Even the dolls become spectators it seems during some.  These scenes juxtaposed with scenes from ‘Applehurst’ and the almost saintly Sister George only heightens the unpredictability of George’s mood swings.

During one scene, almost too repulsive to watch, a ritual between the two (“you know the drill”), George forces Childe to eat her cigar butt.  The rules are broken by Childe though as she chooses to play her own game, acting as though she is enjoying the cigar butt – an act that enrages George who claims “you’re spoiling it for me” and indeed the routine seems to have been damaged forever as George continues with “you know once you spoil something you can never make it work again” – a sentiment that seems to reflect what is happening to their whole relationship.  

Increasingly as the film progresses, their roles seem to change, Childe becomes the adult, George the child and the one who needs to be looked after. 

For me the characters seem to be on the brink of change, and during the first half of the film as we are introduced to George and Childe’s way of living it seems inevitable that the discord in their relationship will lead to a moment where both characters must enter a new phase in their lives.

It takes the introduction of a third character to create this change - and one George does not want, battling and raging against it, becoming more and more frustrated at Childe and the world around her.  Seeing them share the screen and the flat with a third person, as their world is disturbed by the arrival of Mercy Croft (Coral Browne) really feels like an intrusion on what they have.  

Mercy Croft plays the villain in the film, appearing like a stereotypical predatory lesbian who wouldn’t look out of place on the cover of a lesbian pulp fiction book.  Playing the bad guy, she also brings news that Sister George will be axed from ‘Applehurst’. It is clear she has a soft spot for Childe and clearer still she dislikes George, calling her a “dreary, inadequate, drunken old bag” and a “pathetic old dyke”.  

Through Childe’s supposed innocence, George appears the opposite – she is very aware of the dangers a women like Mercy Croft presents (to her). One of the final exchanges between George and Childe leads to one of my favourite quotes in the whole film, with Childe defensively stating, “not all girls are raving bloody lesbians” and George answering, “that’s a misfortune that I’m perfectly aware of”.

Print that on a t-shirt and wear it with pride. 

One of the fascinating moments in the film is when George and Childe, dressed up as Laurel and Hardy, go to the legendary ‘Gateways Club’ in London, where regulars at the club were filmed dancing and acted in scenes.

It was the first time camera coverage was permitted extensively in the club – and for the straight audience watching the film it was a glimpse into a hidden sub-culture.  It is great to have this club documented in the film – it gives us the chance to see how things were and it is perhaps these scenes filmed at the club which date the film most.  Every time I have seen the film I seem to watch with mouth open, a hint of hilarity almost beckoning me to make a joke.  Watch it.  You’ll see what I mean.  It’s great, a female band plays as butch dance with femme and the array hair and clothes merge into one. It makes me slightly yearn for those days, it all seemed less complicated.  

Interestingly Beryl Reid’s account of being in the Gateway Club is not too positive, quoted as saying in her biography, “If I had been here before I did the play I’d never have done it.  I didn’t realise they held each other and went to the gents loo”.
George is ultimately to blame for her downfall, losing both job and relationship.  She is a “bad boy”, assaulting nuns in the back of a taxi, getting repeatedly drunk, fighting with Childe, and walking off set.  And yet, we want to see her survive.  She’s the sort who will stick two fingers up at the powers that be, at rules and regulations and her less than pure sense of humour deserves an audience – at one point Croft remarks how cheerful the character of Sister George looks, in which George says “you’d look cheerful too with 50 cubic centimetres throbbing away between your legs”. 

Although extremely funny there is a much deeper side to George – the strong character we see stomping down pathways at the very beginning of the film needs a place to cry as she learns Childe is lying to her. The torment in her voice as she screams at Childe is almost unbearable.  Here is a woman, with a life slowly being broken down and made unrecognisable by those around her.  

With Sister George now gone, George attends her own leaving party, her anger and frustration never far from boiling over.  Being offered the part of Claribel the Cow in a new children’s programme does nothing to help the situation.  Offended by this offer it could be the lowest she can sink.

However there is one more rung to fall and the blatant advances of Croft upon Childe lead to the inevitable.

I cannot of course write about this film without mentioning the infamous sex scene. I found out recently that Susannah York never felt comfortable with it.  Maybe this is why I always feel  a bit awkward watching it.  At the time it was this sex scene that made the film X rated, although the only nudity we see are Childe’s breasts.  It’s an odd scene, almost devoid of all emotion – there is no passion - and for me seems completely out of place in the film.  The scene does not take place in the play and I wonder why it is included in the film. It’s hard to see its inclusion as anything other than to shock or titillate. 
What did the audiences in the 1960’s think was happening I wonder, since the camera rarely strays from Childe’s face; if they didn’t know what lesbians did in bed they would be left very confused!  Even Croft looks slightly embarrassed and uncomfortable as she kisses Childe, seemingly unsure of what reaction she will get.  

And so the end of the film comes as a relief – the laughs having long gone. Change has finally come and it makes George confront Childe with the question “what’s going to happen?” and then using Childe’s secrets as weapons against her.
Even though Childe admits to being frightened, there is a sense she will be ok.  She turns out to be quite shallow and blasé “Ta ta George thanks for everything” and where we once felt sorry for her, we almost end up not liking her. It is George we are left worrying about and where our sympathies lie. This sympathy and worry is heightened as we see George return to a darkened studio, stumbling around before smashing up the coffin of Sister George.  This turns disturbing as she then collapses on to a bench and screams “Moo!” – a nod towards a future as Claribel the Cow - a desperate and pitying cry, no one around to hear or pay attention to.  She cuts a truly lonely, tragic figure.  Only the lazy could possibly describe this film as a comedy.

This was the first time in a Hollywood film the L word was used. It wasn’t used in the original play and even The Children’s Hour made 6 years previous did not mention it, despite the two females leads being accused of having an affair.

There was almost invisibility to gay women when this film was made; did this film then have a responsibility in making ‘the lesbian’ seen? I’m sure the director/writer was not focussing on portraying lesbians or their relationships in a flattering light.  The characters here however are shone in such an unlikeable light we could even cry ‘unfair’ and ‘shame’ – was this done on purpose I wonder? 

This was never a film made for lesbians, never one to call our own – if you were gay woman watching the film in 1968 it may have left you feeling slightly depressed and it is easy to see why the film received poor reviews from lesbian circles at the time.  Unfortunately I fear many gay women nowadays will feel slightly offended by the portrayal on screen as there is nothing realistic or sensitive about these characters. 

As with The Children’s Hour the film gives the idea that all lesbian relationships end in tears. It would take perhaps another 17 years before we would get the love story we wanted in Desert Hearts.  

To conclude then – yes the film is very dated in places. I was actually left wishing I could see the play.  Although quite an uncomfortable film to watch – the torturous arguments and tension is at times wearying, there is a lot to like, some hilarious writing and not to hear it would be missing out.

Perhaps it deserves to be held up with a little more respect if only for the energetic and flawless performance of Beryl Reid. It isn’t easy playing a character that flips from comic to tragic and she is the life and soul of the film.  And we only have to look at how our own feelings change towards George to see how successful she is in playing the role.


Watch… but don’t expect an easy ride.

Review by Caz Maughan

Monday, 18 April 2011

The Children's Hour at Comedy Theatre

Eyebrows and righteousness

Ellen BurstynWe sat down in our stall seats (purchased on the day for £15 – well worth turning up to the box office at 10am that morning)* with high expectations. The Children’s Hour is one of my favourite plays, but I wasn’t sure anyone could beat Shirley MacLaine’s performance as the turmoiled Miss Dolby from the 1961 film of the play. I was not disappointed. 

I had tried to avoid any reviews of the play as I wanted to watch it with fresh eyes and be entertained and moved, and that I was. The performances from the leads and supports were all stellar - well polished, smooth, and for me Ellen Burstyn stood out, hitting the nail right on the head with her portrayal of Amelia Tilford – devoted grandmother, powerful family figure head, embodiment of American Middle Class righteousness. 

Keira Knightley’s eyebrows deserve an Olivier all by themselves, as they arched in surprise so beautifully, even if her accent did wobble a little. 

A lot has been made of the performance of the Lynch-pin character, Mary, outshining Knightley and Moss. Easy to do when the character allows for a show stealing turn, but what was most important was the juxtaposition of a poisonous, selfish child to two hard working good women. The subtlety of the under played teachers was what impressed me.  

Two scenes really stood out. First, the start of the second Act, where the 5 leads play out the confrontation. It contained the right amount of tension, vindication and heartbreak to set up a dramatic second Act. The final scene stood out for me, and Knightley’s outpour to a now broken Amelia Tilford (victim of her own blindness and sheer stubbornness) was incredibly powerful and haunting. 

My only criticism of the production is some questionable direction. I think given the theatre and visibility, the director, Ian Rickson tried to ensure action took place across the stage, however it meant a lot of the scenes were blocked by having the actors walk from one side to the other. The scenes that worked best were those with little movement, where the actors just did their thing.

*To ensure you get tickets, arrive around 9am and expect to queue. The box office does open at 10 on the dot, and all the remaining seats for that night’s performance are sold for £15 each, which is a real bargain as top priced seats for this play go for £85. These tickets are limited to 2 per person, so if you are planning to watch the play in a group make sure enough people turn up at 10am!

Review by Katie Hall

Desert Hearts - string of lights

Date:               Saturday 9th April 2011
Location:
        Rio Cinema, Dalston

Desert Hearts… I can’t even mention the name without smiling. 

This was the film that made me fall in love with being in love (and ever since, I’ve been waiting for my very own Cay Rivvers!).  I think my whole idea of how being in love should be is based on this film.  The film set my expectations back when I was 18 years old,  in my darkened bedroom, earphones plugged into my portable black and white (not wanting my parents to hear I was still up), and urging Cay to ‘Get on the train!’  in a whispered shout at the screen.

I had not seen the film on the big screen before, so imagine my joy to find out Desert Hearts had been voted by readers of website The Most Cake to be shown as part of the Fringe Festival.  The Fringe Festival is a DIY London Gay Film Festival set up in response to the cuts that caused the London Lesbian and Gay Film Festival to be trimmed down this year.   It’s non-profit, organised by a team of folk over Facebook and offered an array of events, shorts and films.  See www.facebook.com/fringefilmfest for further information.

Desert Hearts (1985)is based on the novel Desert of the Heart by Jane Rule,  and is testament to actors Helen Shaver, Patricia Charbonneau and director Donna Deitch that it can still holds its own. The acting is strong and believable, and at the time it was a groundbreaking film.. It was unheard of to have a full-length lesbian love story with such a positive portrayal of lesbians on screen, and also unusual for it not to end in suicide or a broken heart. It really is a celebration of every shiver, tingle, grin of falling in love.

And this was all done with only a budget of $350,000.

It paved the way for many lesbian films and in fact the producers of the L Word got the actors to watch Desert Hearts.  It is well regarded as having what remains one of the best lesbian love scenes, and although explicit it is not exploitative.  It is tender, well directed and feels much more real than anything else I’ve seen so far.  It works both sexually and emotionally.
For both Shaver and Charbonneau, the film became life and career changing – it remains for both the only film where they both play lead roles and having read through interviews with them I feel they have a sense of pride in having done the film – despite being advised not to by friends at the time.  

On a day with sunshine and a blue sky to match that of Reno, Dalston’s Rio Cinema played host to the showing of this film.  Yes, on one of the warmest days of the year so far, a bunch of women sat in a darkened cinema screen and turned back the years. No one minded sacrificing a few hours of sunshine for time spent watching this lesbian classic.  

Seeing the original cinema poster up at the Rio I was transported back in time.  Sadly there weren’t overflowing queues of lesbians I had envisaged .  However the foyer filled quickly, and with the opportunity to get your photo taken dressed as a cowgirl complete with hat, leather jacket and cactus, it quickly became fun to people-watch and enjoy the build up to this event. As tickets were collected, popcorn sold and groups of people chatted, a roller skating usherette dressed as a cowgirl offered cupcakes. 

Speaking to some of those in attendance beforehand I was surprised to learn of how many hadn’t seen the film before.  I think I was expecting the audiences to be full of Desert Heart devotees as this film was such a rite of passage for me.

Making myself comfortable in the screen, I vowed to the folk sitting near me that I wouldn’t scream, shout, cry or be over-emotional at any point. I actually felt as though this would be quite impossible at the time but you’ll be pleased to hear I did manage to control myself, submerging myself into the film and atmosphere of the screen – a smile playing on the corners of my mouth in the darkness.

After an introduction (complete with cactus on stage) from Anna (Fringe Festival) and Kitty (Most Cake) the lights went down and the chatter faded. I felt the same excitement I get when I’m at a gig and the lights godown – it surprised me as I have never felt this way about a film before. The film started, Helen Shaver’s name provoking a semi-cheer when it came up on screen.

The plot is simple, set in the 1950’s, an English professor, Vivian Bell (Helen Shaver) goes to Reno whilst divorcing her husband.  She books into a ranch run by Frances Parker (Audra Lindley) and in the process meets Frances; step daughter, Cay Rivvers (Patricia Chabonneau). The films unfolds with Cay and Vivian being drawn together, along the way struggling with conflicting desires but ultimately falling in love with each other.  It is a true love story.  

I feel it is impossible not to like Vivian and Cay.  Although Vivian seems to take more of a journey - her life has been all about order, her fears of what people will think of her stopping her from being with Cay, and during the film she changes into someone figuring out how she is going to live her life as a freer person – which includes having a relationship with another woman. (Even her dress reflects her evolution). As for Cay, well, she leaps off the screen, a free spirit who knows what she wants, who isn’t conventional, but who is still determined to have it; striving to meet someone who ‘counts’. She is passionate and romantic, believing Vivian is ‘the one’ and not letting go.  

Neither character is the stereotypical lesbian and both are played with a sensitivity that had been lacking in any previous attempts to portray lesbians on the big screen. 

Set against a backdrop of country music which enhances the mood of the characters – seeing Cay drive downtown Reno to the Patsy Cline’s “Crazy” provokes a feeling of restlessness and a yearning, which although seemingly impossible will not be reined in – the film’s success owes a lot to the chemistry between the two leads.  Their relationship builds slowly and each time they share the screen it feels as though their bond is getting stronger. Despite the emotional turmoil there is no disguising the desire they feel of each other.  

Their first kiss is absolutely wonderful and beautifully shows off the allure between Shaver and Charbonneau:
Cay:
[after Vivian breaks away from a passionate kiss] We don't have to stop.
Vivian:
I do.
Cay:
Where did you learn to kiss like that?
Vivian
: I don't know where that came from. It's back where it belongs, and I don't want to talk about it anymore.

I’d forgotten how humourous the film is – whether or not it intended to be or not – and the audience laughed along, a perfect example of Vivian’s quick wit: 
Lucille:
“Nobody said it didn’t take all kinds, Vivian”
Vivian:
“And you’re certainly making a unique contribution”
 
Causing amusement as well as Cay’s blatant advances towards Vivian, which constantly tickled the audience. The loudest laugh though was reserved for the moment Vivian, realising “My only clear memory is arriving. The rest is a blur. An absolute blur” then turns to see a half naked Cay in bed, waiting for her. 


Which leads of course to much celebrated sex scene.  I wondered what reaction it would get and was surprised when stillness swept over the screen.  It was almost as though the cinema were holding its breath. I’m not sure what I was expecting, cheering, laughter, clapping, jeering, cheering?  It felt to me like people were respecting the scene. Total silence made every sound on screen amplified.  I’d never heard a kiss so loud.  

The film slowly sauntered into the sunset with a satisfying glow, applause from the audience was quickly followed by the buzz of conversation as people made their way back out into the bright sunshine.  The foyer seemed full only momentarily as folk made good use of the rest of the blue sky and sun, perhaps wondering where Vivian and Cay would be now if they were real…  

Talking to Fringe Festival Liz it was fascinating to learn the Desert Hearts film reel shown was the only copy in Europe and it had been challenging getting hold of it.   It is further evidence to the power of the film – and the hearsay surrounding it perhaps that it got the most votes. Incidentally, ‘But I’m a Cheerleader’ came second, closely followed by ‘Show me Love’ and then ‘High Art’.  

I was interested to see how people felt after watching the film, particularly those who has never seen it.  There seemed to be a general feeling that although looking slightly dated – more down to costume – it stood up well, with story and characters liked. And although I had never seen it as a comical film when I had first seen it, opinions were united in describing it as funny.

For me, eighteen years have passed, and I saw the film differently this time, realising the humour this time around.  And yet, it still holds that magic for me.  It is still beautiful and tender. Maybe I’m just a complete romantic but no matter how corny some lines seem, they still sound like a rendezvous with ‘what someone should say’.

It is lines like “being with you is starting to hurt” and “we’ve been saying goodbye from the beginning” that I fell in love with first time round, and no matter how cheesy this dialogue seems I find it almost lyrical. I want to carry them around, write them down, say them, dip them in chocolate, run away with them, watch them build a happy home together.  

What intrigued me was how different it felt watching the film with 100 other people.  I’d only ever seen the film on my own – it’s a very personal film because of that.  I felt very much like I was letting the audience into a world I’d only ever known, letting people into my bedroom almost.  I wanted to stand up at the end and take a bow, I was delighted when they laughed at the jokes – for they were my jokes – and glad to hear how they had enjoyed the film afterwards – for it was my film.

I still held my breath when Cay leant in to Vivian in the rain.  The rain in that scene only seems to make it more intense, watching it drip from Cay’s hair is a moment of beauty.   And the expression on Cay’s face reminds me somehow of my first kiss.  That excitement, the first touch of her lips on mine, and my eyes wide as we slowly drew apart.  I thought my eyes would not close that night.  I felt like I’d been hit in the face by the most beautiful escape.It felt wonderful to be re-acquainted with that naïve girl who was once me, when all I had to base any desire on was this movie. 

I wonder what a new generation will make of Desert Hearts, it feels timeless for me. I realised one of the things I love the most about the film is it’s pace – the characters build up their relationship before they share a bed. The way the story slowly unfolds is very much down to Deitch’s direction and it feels very different from today’s films and dramas where it all seems so instant.

It isn’t about the glitz and the glam, there are no funky hairdos (well…), no swearing, drugs.  It is a love story.  Pure and simple.  And as a love story, it still works. And anyone who believes in wanting a string of lights around their heart will absolutely bask in its brilliance.  

The sequel is in the making; rumoured to be set in New York in the late 60’s early 70’s and featuring both Cay and Vivian as well as other characters.  I for one cannot wait to catch up with them. For more information, visit the Donna Deitch website.

Review by Caz Maughan

Friday, 25 February 2011

Flaunt

Date:    the Launch Friday 25 February 2011

Flaunt-astic

Taking place over three floors, plus the urban roof terrace, of the refurbished Kings Cross-iconic ‘Driver’, this retro-modern pop, urban-hip-hip-soul and house event delivered what it had promised.

Making excellent use of the intimate and cosy upper levels of the Driver, candle-light and sofas, plenty of dance space, and the glorious roof top view of the terrace, offered something for everyone; and it was a truly eclectic crowd, a real highlight for Planet London was to be sharing the dance floor with a mix of lesbians we wouldn’t normally see on a night out. 

Also celebrating 15 years of the Glass Bar – another Central London icon, to which many lesbians often say they owe a lot of thanks.

© Planet-London.com 2011-2013

Part of the Ultimate Planet universe: Ultimate Planet | Planet London | Planet Publishing | Planet PR and Marketing | Planet Fiction

About | Advertise with us | Privacy | Terms and conditions | Sitemap